Home / Personal Injury / Birth Injuries

Birth Injury Lawyer in Middletown, NY

When a birth injury occurs because of a preventable medical error, families in Orange County are left facing a future they never anticipated, one that may include long-term disability, intensive therapy, and significant financial strain. These injuries are not simply unfortunate outcomes; in many cases, they reflect a failure by healthcare providers to meet the standard of care owed to mother and child.

At Rolo Law, our attorneys represent families whose children have suffered birth injuries caused by medical negligence. If you believe your child’s injury was preventable, contact our legal team today at 845-668-4774 to discuss what happened and learn about your options.

What Counts as a Birth Injury Under New York Law?

A birth injury generally refers to physical harm sustained by a child before, during, or shortly after birth. When the injury results from a healthcare provider’s departure from the accepted standard of care, and that departure caused the injury, it may support a medical malpractice claim under New York law. Not every birth injury results from negligence, and the facts of each case must be evaluated individually.

New York medical malpractice law requires proof of four elements:

  • Duty: the healthcare provider owed a duty of care to the patient.
  • Breach: the provider deviated from the accepted standard of care.
  • Causation: that deviation directly caused the child’s injury.
  • Damages: the injury resulted in measurable harm, such as disability, medical expenses, or developmental delays.

Not all birth injuries meet this threshold. Some result from unforeseeable complications, not negligence. A thorough investigation of medical records, delivery logs, and fetal monitoring data is required to determine whether negligence was a contributing factor.

Common Birth Injuries Linked to Medical Negligence

Common birth injuries that may give rise to a medical malpractice claim include brain damage from oxygen deprivation, brachial plexus injuries causing Erb’s palsy, spinal cord injuries, and fractures sustained during a difficult delivery.

  • Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE): A type of brain injury associated with reduced oxygen and blood flow to the brain. HIE can occur around the time of birth and may lead to lasting neurological impairments, including developmental difficulties and motor disorders. Whether a healthcare provider’s failure to recognize fetal distress, respond appropriately, or perform a timely C-section contributed to the injury depends on the medical evidence and the circumstances of the delivery.
  • Erb’s Palsy: A brachial plexus injury affecting the nerves controlling the arm and shoulder, typically caused by excessive force or improper traction during delivery. Severity ranges from temporary weakness to permanent paralysis.
  • Cerebral Palsy: A group of disorders affecting movement, muscle tone, and posture that result from injury to or abnormal development of the developing brain. Cerebral palsy can have various causes, including complications before, during, or after birth. In some cases, a medical error may contribute to the brain injury, but cerebral palsy alone does not establish that medical malpractice occurred. Signs may become apparent during infancy, and diagnosis can take time.
  • Spinal Cord Injuries: Injuries to the spinal cord that may result in weakness, sensory impairment, or paralysis. Although some injuries may be associated with birth trauma or delivery complications, determining whether improper handling or another medical error caused the injury requires an individualized review of the medical evidence.
  • Facial Nerve Injuries and Skull Fractures: These injuries can occur in connection with delivery, including deliveries involving forceps or vacuum extractors. Whether the use of an instrument was improper, fell below the accepted standard of care, or caused a particular injury depends on the circumstances and medical evidence.

Medical Errors That Commonly Cause Birth Injuries

Birth injuries are often caused by failures in monitoring, delayed intervention, or improper delivery technique, all of which may constitute medical malpractice when they fall below the accepted standard of care.

A Middletown birth injury case may arise when:

  • Failure to monitor fetal distress: missing or ignoring signs of fetal distress can lead to oxygen deprivation and brain damage.
  • Delayed C-section: an unreasonable delay in ordering an emergency C-section when vaginal delivery becomes dangerous is a recognized basis for a claim.
  • Improper use of delivery instruments: misapplied forceps and vacuum extractors can cause brachial plexus injuries and skull fractures.
  • Medication and dosing errors: inappropriate dosing or administration of Pitocin or other labor-inducing medications may cause excessive uterine contractions and potentially compromise fetal oxygen supply. Whether a medication error contributed to a birth injury depends on the dosage, monitoring, clinical circumstances, and medical evidence.
  • Failure to address maternal infections: certain maternal infections, including Group B streptococcal infection, can pose risks to a newborn if appropriate screening, preventive treatment, or management is not provided when indicated. Some neonatal infections can lead to serious complications, including neurological injury. Whether a failure to follow appropriate medical practices caused or contributed to an injury requires review of the specific circumstances.

What Damages Can a Family Recover in a Birth Injury Lawsuit?

In a New York birth injury lawsuit, a family may seek compensation for the child’s past and future medical care, rehabilitation costs, lost earning capacity, and pain and suffering, as well as wrongful death damages when the injury is fatal.

  • Medical expenses: hospital stays, surgeries, and ongoing treatment tied to the birth injury.
  • Future medical care: decades of specialized care, adaptive equipment, and residential support for children with permanent disability.
  • Physical therapy and rehabilitation: physical, occupational, and speech therapy.
  • Lost wages and caregiving expenses: a child’s birth injury may create substantial financial pressure on a family. Depending on the circumstances and applicable law, recoverable damages may include certain reasonable expenses associated with the child’s care. A parent’s lost income from reducing or leaving employment is not automatically recoverable as damages in the child’s medical malpractice action, and any separate claim must be evaluated under the applicable law.
  • Pain and suffering: compensation may be available for the child’s pain, suffering, and other legally recognized noneconomic harm resulting from the injury. Whether a parent may recover separate damages for emotional distress or other personal losses depends on the specific facts and applicable law.
  • Wrongful death: when a birth injury results in death, the child’s personal representative may pursue a wrongful death claim on behalf of eligible beneficiaries under New York law. Recoverable damages may include reasonable funeral expenses and qualifying pecuniary losses suffered by the distributees. The availability and amount of damages depend on the evidence and applicable law.

New York’s Statute of Limitations for Birth Injury Cases

New York imposes strict time limits on birth injury cases. Under CPLR § 214-a, a medical malpractice claim generally must be filed within two years and six months of the alleged malpractice, subject to statutory exceptions. For claims brought on behalf of injured minors, CPLR § 208 generally extends the filing deadline for infancy, but the extension for medical malpractice claims is subject to a 10-year limit measured from the date the claim accrues. The applicable deadline depends on the circumstances of the alleged malpractice and the child’s claim, so families should seek legal advice promptly.

Under New York CPLR § 208, infancy may extend the statute of limitations for a child’s claim. However, medical malpractice claims are subject to a special 10-year limit on the infancy extension. The deadline can depend on when the claim accrued and whether a statutory exception applies. Because these rules can be complex, families should consult an attorney as early as possible. Waiting reduces the availability of evidence and can compromise a family’s ability to seek fair compensation.

How a Birth Injury Claim Proceeds in New York

A New York birth injury claim begins with a thorough investigation of medical records and expert review to determine whether negligence occurred, and proceeds through settlement negotiations or trial to secure compensation for the child’s injury.

New York requires a Certificate of Merit under CPLR § 3012-a in medical malpractice actions. The certificate is executed by the plaintiff’s attorney and generally confirms that the attorney has reviewed the facts, consulted with at least one appropriately qualified physician licensed in New York or another state, and concluded that there is a reasonable basis for commencing the action. The statute provides an exception when the attorney cannot reasonably obtain the required consultation before the applicable filing deadline expires. Key stages include:

  1. Case evaluation and records review: medical records, delivery notes, fetal monitoring strips, and nursing logs are collected and analyzed.
  2. Expert consultation: independent medical experts assess whether the standard of care was breached and whether that breach caused the injury.
  3. Filing and discovery: both sides exchange evidence, take depositions, and retain expert witnesses.
  4. Settlement negotiations: some birth injury cases resolve through settlement negotiations. The amount of any settlement depends on factors such as the evidence of liability, the nature and extent of the child’s injuries, anticipated future care needs, and the applicable law. No particular outcome or settlement amount can be guaranteed.
  5. Trial: when a fair settlement cannot be reached, the case proceeds before a jury.

Our attorneys handle all aspects of this process; to discuss your Middletown birth injury case, call 845-668-4774.

Frequently Asked Questions About Birth Injury Cases in New York

Is my child’s injury a birth defect or a birth injury?

A birth defect is a structural or functional condition that develops before birth and may have genetic, environmental, developmental, or other causes. A birth injury generally refers to physical harm sustained before, during, or shortly after birth. Some birth injuries occur despite appropriate medical care, while others may result from negligence. A medical malpractice claim requires evidence that a healthcare provider failed to meet the applicable standard of care and that the failure caused the injury. A review of medical records by an experienced birth injury attorney is usually necessary to make this determination.

Can I file a birth injury claim years after the delivery?

Possibly, but the deadline depends on the circumstances of the claim. New York generally provides a two-year-and-six-month limitations period for medical malpractice claims, and the infancy extension for medical malpractice claims is subject to a 10-year limit. Different rules may apply depending on when the alleged malpractice occurred, when the claim accrued, and whether an exception applies. Families should consult a birth injury lawyer in Middletown as soon as possible rather than assume they have until the child’s 21st birthday.

What if the injury was caused by a hospital, not just one doctor?

Hospitals may be held directly liable when their own negligent acts or omissions, such as certain staffing failures, equipment problems, or inadequate protocols, cause injury. They may also be vicariously liable for negligent acts committed by employees acting within the scope of their employment. Liability for independent physicians and other healthcare providers depends on the circumstances and applicable law. A thorough investigation can help determine which individuals or entities may be legally responsible.

Do I have to pay upfront legal fees to pursue a birth injury case?

Contact Rolo Law at 845-668-4774 to discuss how our attorneys handle birth injury cases and what to expect regarding fees and the legal process.

What if my child suffered a birth injury and later passed away?

New York law allows the family to pursue a wrongful death claim and a survival action for injuries sustained before death. These claims can recover medical expenses, funeral costs, and compensation for the family’s loss. Wrongful death actions are governed by EPTL § 5-4.1, which generally requires filing within two years of the date of death, subject to applicable statutory exceptions. A related medical malpractice or survival claim may have a different deadline, so the applicable time limits should be evaluated separately.

Speak With a Birth Injury Lawyer in Middletown, NY

Your child’s birth injury deserves a serious, thorough legal response. Rolo Law represents families throughout Middletown, Orange County, and the surrounding New York region seeking fair compensation after preventable harm during delivery. Our attorneys are prepared to investigate the circumstances of your child’s injury, consult independent medical experts, and pursue every avenue of recovery on your family’s behalf.

Call us at 845-668-4774 to speak with our team about your birth injury case.

Get A Free Consultation

Reach out to our team to discuss your legal matter. We're here to listen, answer your questions, and explain your options.

Get A Free Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

Scroll to Top